Solar Generators vs. Gas Generators: Which Is Right for You?

Last updated: December 5, 2024

Power requirements, cost, and environmental impact are generally the deciding factors when selecting a generator. Depending on your unique needs, gas and solar generators have unique benefits. Solar generators have low running costs, are silent, and are excellent for powering small gadgets. On the other hand, gas generators are perfect for heavy-duty applications since they provide more reliable and instantaneous power but also cost more to maintain and fuel. This article will examine both types to help you decide which generator is appropriate for your needs.


What are Solar & Gas Generators?

Solar Generators

A solar generator is a portable power device that harnesses solar energy. An inverter transforms stored energy into usable electricity, and solar panels are combined with a battery for storage. This integrated system offers a quiet, clean, and sustainable energy source.

How do they work?

Evolution GEN2800 Evo Generator 2400W

Evolution GEN2800 Evo Generator 2400W

SIP 25124 Medusa T2500W Generator

SIP 25124 Medusa T2500W Generator


Gas Generators

Gas generators burn fossil fuels like natural gas, propane, or gasoline to create electricity. They are renowned for producing large amounts of power and being dependable in providing steady energy in times of need.

How do they work?

Hyundai P4000i 3800W Portable Petrol Inverter Generator

Hyundai P4000i 3800W Portable Petrol Inverter Generator

Hyundai DHY8000SELR-T 6kW/7.5kVA Multi-phase Silenced Long Run Diesel Generator

Hyundai DHY8000SELR-T 6kW/7.5kVA Multi-phase Silenced Long Run Diesel Generator


Solar & Gas Generator Use Cases

Home Use

Solar: Ideal for small to medium appliances, with no fuel costs and minimal maintenance.
Gas: Suitable for large appliances like refrigerators and HVAC systems but requires regular fuel and maintenance.

High-Power Tasks

Solar: Limited power for large appliances, recharges slowly in low sunlight.
Gas: Reliable for high-power needs, can run multiple heavy-duty tools and appliances simultaneously.

Construction Sites

Solar: Less suitable for heavy-duty tools, slow to recharge, can’t power large equipment.
Gas: Best for construction sites due to high power output, instant use, and reliability.

Emergency Backups

Solar: Suitable for powering essential appliances like lights and chargers during outages.
Gas: Better for providing long-term backup for large power loads like HVAC or heating systems.

Short-Term Use

Solar: Quiet, eco-friendly, powers small devices like phones, lights, and small appliances.
Gas: Noisy, emits fumes, not ideal for small, enclosed spaces.


Comparison Factors

FactorsSolar GeneratorGas Generator
CostHigher initial cost but lower long-term costsCheaper at first, but continuing fuel and maintenance expenses can mount up.
Power OutputIdeal for small to medium-sized devices, it is less dependable for high-power requirements and requires sunlight for recharging.Dependable, powerful, and capable of handling large loads right away.
Environment ImpactSilent, zero emissions, eco-friendly.Noisy and emits greenhouse gases, making it unsuitable for interior use.
Maintenance & LifespanLong lifespan (10-25 years) with minimal maintenance requirements.Requires regular maintenance, and fuel availability may be a problem.
Ease of UseLightweight, portable, safe for indoor use.Easy to use, however must be used outdoors due to emissions.

Which Works Best for You?

Consider your power requirements when selecting which type of generator works best for you. Select a solar generator for portability and environmental friendliness and a gas generator for heavy power requirements like construction or major appliances. Gas generators are initially less expensive but need constant fuel and maintenance, whereas solar generators are emissions-free but more expensive. Choose according to your budget, power requirements, and environmental preferences.

Draper 16066 Petrol Generator with Wheels (2.2kVA/2.0kW)

Draper 16066 Petrol Generator with Wheels (2.2kVA/2.0kW)

SIP 03920 Medusa T951 2-Stroke Compact Generator 750W 230V

SIP 03920 Medusa T951 2-Stroke Compact Generator 750W 230V


FAQ

Are solar generators worth the higher upfront cost?

Due to their low maintenance requirements and reliance on solar energy, solar generators are more expensive initially but save you money over time. Additionally, they have fewer recurring costs and typically have a greater life span than gas generators.

Can I use a solar generator in cloudy weather?

Although they won’t be as effective, solar generators can operate under overcast conditions. Depending on battery capacity, they can still supply electricity, but it may take longer to recharge, and energy storage might be required during overcast conditions.

How do I choose the right size gas generator?

The total wattage of the equipment you intend to power will help you select the best gas generator. To cover power surges, use a generator that can manage 20–30% more wattage than your total output.


Need some help with your order? Our new help centre has a wide range of helpful articles and guides!

If you have any additional queries, please do not hesitate to contact us at 01358 726719 or by email at admin@toolden.co.uk